Skip to content
Search ESC
Enterprise Advisory Scorecard (PDF)

Agentic AI Vendor Evaluation Scorecard

Procurement-Ready Scoring For Advisory And Platform Decisions

A structured scorecard for comparing agentic AI vendors, advisory partners, and platform options. Focuses on architecture judgment, governance depth, production evidence, vendor neutrality, and capability transfer.

What's covered

Inside the scorecard

01

Evaluation Dimensions

  • Architecture judgment
  • Governance and control-plane depth
  • Production proof
  • Vendor neutrality
  • Capability transfer
  • Budget discipline
02

Committee Review Sheet

  • Technical champion notes
  • Procurement questions
  • Security/legal flags
  • Board or executive concerns
03

Red Flags

  • Implementation-first without design criteria
  • Vendor lock-in bias
  • No artifacts beyond slides
  • No evidence of when not to build agents
04

Shortlist Memo

  • Scoring summary
  • Key trade-offs
  • Recommendation rationale
  • Pilot or advisory next step
Next Step

Turn this into a decision path leadership can use

Use this resource to frame the decision, then move into the advisory path that defines governance, prioritization, and the next architecture step.

See Agentic Portfolio Review

Need direct intake instead? Submit Specs.